What we can learn from failed Doomsday prophets

False Prophets and Prophecies

Watching the spectacle of doomsday unfold, I was taken back to the 1980s. It was 1984 or 85 when a rare occurrence was taking place in the heavens. Several planets were lining up with the earth. I don’t remember the details or how many planets made up the chain, but I do remember the false prophets and doomsday doctrines spreading fear in a similar fashion as we saw yesterday, May 21st, 2011.

People were quoting out of context scriptures and using phrases like, “You will see signs in the heavens.” As was the case with Harold Camping’s followers, doomsday advocates warned everyone that the rapture and judgment were coming. The rapture was to come at the exact moment the planets aligned. In the 1980s spectacle, believers climbed on their rooftops and waited for the rapture. They shrugged off ridicule from neighbors and naysayers knowing they would be snatched away at any moment. Morning came and dejected believers climbed off their houses to face embarrassment of being wrong amid the snickers of skeptics.

People forget and new false prophets will arise

Memories will fade and a new enlightened false prophets will arise to draw disciples after themselves, and the process will start again. Perhaps this should be a learning experience. What went wrong? How do we know what the truth is? Someone posted a question to me asking, “Who are you to decide which prophet is wrong, or which interpretation is wrong? The Bible can be interpreted many ways, so who is to say which is the right way?”

In the aftermath of this public spectacle, it might be beneficial to answer this question. Many asked how could I have been so certain when I posted the reasons why yesterday’s prophecy was destined to fail. I won’t answer that question again since my last post addresses that. But I will answer the question as to how we know which interpretation is correct. The answer to this question is the guard against future spectacles. The world rejoices when the church is made into a group of fools. Whether you believed Camping or not, you are still ‘one of those Christians’ in the eyes of the world.

False Prophets are often deceived themselves

The first clue came from the video posted by Robert Fitzpatrick. He was the author of ‘The Doomsday Code’, avid Camping follower, and the one being berated at Time Square after 6:00 p.m. passed by without an earthquake or rapture. In an interview he posted on the internet, he made the following comment, “People read a verse that says, ‘No one will know the day nor the hour,’ and they stop there. But you have to go a little deeper and do some digging.”

Let’s stop here and think about what he said. There are many things wrong with the predictions of his video, but rather than rebutting, let’s look at the foundation of the problem. When the disciples asked Jesus when the end would come, His answer was that no one knows. Not the angels, not men, not even the Son. Only the Father knows. When Jesus rose from the grave, his disciples again asked a question about the future. “Will you now restore the kingdom?” His answer was, “It is not for you to know times or seasons which the Father has put under his own authority.”

In every situation where end times were mentioned, the Bible makes it clear that we are to be watching always so we are ready, but it is not given for man to know when God plans to fulfill all things. Our role is not to know the times, but to walk in a Christ centered life.

This helps to identify the root of the problem. False prophets places their authority over the word. Followers will place the prophet above the word. In scripture we see Jesus saying, ‘you cannot know’, and the way of error says, ‘you can’t stop there, you have to dig deeper and find out the hidden secrets.’

Why dig deeper? If Jesus said, “It is not for you to know,” then we should stop there. Why try to root out what God has plainly stated he will not reveal to us. Sure you can dig out secrets and hidden things. All false prophets discover hidden knowledge they claim to only have the power to interpret. However, since God said he will not reveal, what they find cannot be from God.

You Can Know

You can know the truth and each person can interpret the scriptures accurately. To the question, who can know, the answer is simple. But that answer is based on what God has plainly stated. 2 Peter 1:20-21

20 knowing this first, that no prophecy of Scripture is of any private interpretation,
21 for prophecy never came by the will of man, but holy men of God spoke as they were moved by the Holy Spirit.

Knowing this first. What Peter explains to the church begins with this basic truth. Anything you see in scripture was given by the Holy Spirit and is interpreted according to the Holy Spirit, and is plain to all. It isn’t a secret you discover, but the scripture is the plainly stated word of God. The word ‘prophecy’ doesn’t mean prediction. The word comes from ‘propheteia’ and means: divinely inspired declarations of God’s purposes. That could include the foretelling of future events in scripture, but it applies to everything God has inspired through the word.

Camping, like many false prophets before him, claimed that these hidden truths were not discernable by anyone not given the gift to see it. Yet the Bible affirms that the word was given once for all believers, and is profitable to give doctrine, reproof, correction, and instruction to the believer for the purpose of equipping you for every good work.

This is exactly why 1 John 2:26 begins by warning that there will be those trying to deceive you by claiming to have an anointing, but you do not need anyone to teach you because if you’re a child of God, you have the Holy Spirit and the anointing to know all things. This does not mean teaching doesn’t have a role, for the Bible explains that teachers are gifted and appointed by God for the purpose of equipping the saints. Equipping – not making people into dependents.

The message John is explaining is not that the church doesn’t need teachers, but that you as the individual Christian, are not dependent on a teacher to study the scriptures and discover God’s truth. And we know that what we discover will be consistent with the rest of the scriptures. Once someone claims to have an anointing the rest of us don’t have, it should be a red flag.

So how do we know what the correct interpretation is? According to the Bible, we must diligently study to show ourselves approved by God so we can rightly divide the word of truth. We rightly divide by first knowing the context of a passage. By context, we must know how it fits into the passages that surround it so we can understand the thought being communicated, and then how it fits into the context of the rest of the scriptures.

As with the case of all false prophets, the deception of Camping’s followers and the shameful spectacle that ensued came behind a consistent rejection of the warnings of scripture. When the Bible warned his followers, the leadership persuaded them to ignore the checks and guidance of scripture, and follow another way. Deception requires a willing participation. Anytime anyone is asked to bypass passages that contradict leaders, deception is at the door.

This will happen again. The Bible says that as the day draws near, many false teachers will arise and draw disciples after themselves. In each case, the deceived will have rejected the warnings of scripture in order to be led astray. Camping didn’t predict from the Bible. He added a timeline and formula he came up with to selected passages in order to predict. It was the Bible plus Harold Camping’s formula. The Bible + personal ideology = disaster.

Not all poor teachers are a false prophets, and not every mistake is an intentional deception, but we do know that the Bible corrects error. This is especially true when those propagating the error are among us. You can know the truth, but it requires diligently applying ourselves to the study of the word.

Diligently study so you are not led into error – and you know how to answer when difficult situations arise.

Eddie Snipes
05/2011

Why the Rapture isn’t May 21st

The claim behind the prediction of the rapture:

Watching the followers of Pastor Camping explain the rapture is disheartening. Several of them have stated they quit their jobs and planned their finances to run out today, May 21st. As his people stated in an interview, The rapture and the end of the world“There is no plan B.”

According to Camping’s statements in an interview, the rapture is to occur exactly 7,000 years after the flood. Today is that date by Camping’s calculations.

His reasoning is that the Apostle Peter said, “With the Lord a day is like a thousand years.” Since God said, “I will send a flood in seven days”, the earth will end 7,000 years from the date of that statement. However, people seem to forget the rest of Peter’s statement, “and a thousand years is like a day.” Now if we apply the same logic to the second half of the verse, calculations suddenly don’t make sense. Perhaps the point of Peter’s statement isn’t a coded message, but a reminder that time is not a boundary to God. Whether it’s a thousand years, or a single day, God is there and unaffected by time. We are bound by time, He is not.

Reasons why rapture predictions don’t pan out

Aside from the fact that Harold Camping predicted the rapture and end of the world in 1994, there are specific biblical reasons why the world won’t end today. The first and most obvious is Jesus’ statement in Mark 13:32-33

32 ” But of that day and hour no one knows, not even the angels in heaven, nor the Son, but only the Father.
33 “Take heed, watch and pray; for you do not know when the time is.

How is it that people who claim to be Bible scholars who predict the rapture never seem to understand what Jesus said to his disciples? If Jesus said no one knows – not even the Son – doesn’t it stand to reason that a preacher or Bible scholar can’t know either? Do they have more understanding than Christ? Apparently not. 41 times since 1900 the end of the world has been predicted. 41 times they failed. Today will be the 42nd failure.

Camping’s followers attempt to explain away Jesus’ comments, but there is no escaping the plain truth staring us in the eye. Not only did He say, “No one can know the day or hour,” but he also said, “You do not know when the time is.” Let’s take a glance at the rest of Jesus’ explanation. He mentioned this in each of the gospels, but Luke gives the most details. Luke 12:42-46

42 And the Lord said, “Who then is that faithful and wise steward, whom his master will make ruler over his household, to give them their portion of food in due season?
43 “Blessed is that servant whom his master will find so doing when he comes.
44 “Truly, I say to you that he will make him ruler over all that he has.
45 “But if that servant says in his heart, ‘My master is delaying his coming,’ and begins to beat the male and female servants, and to eat and drink and be drunk,
46 “the master of that servant will come on a day when he is not looking for him, and at an hour when he is not aware, and will cut him in two and appoint him his portion with the unbelievers.

Can you pick out the instruction being communicated in this passage? The point Jesus is making is simple to understand. First, He will come when you are not watching or expecting it. That tosses May 21st off the prophetic calendar.

The purpose of Jesus’ foretelling His return (i.e. the rapture)

The purpose of prophecy is not to predict God and try to outguess him, but to know how to watch. If God gave a date, no one would be caught unaware. The whole purpose of waiting and watching is to determine who is faithful and who is not. The unfaithful only keep their house in order when they think they are being watched. That is human nature. When we know the boss is coming, we make sure we look busy, the office is clean, and everything is in order. But a surprise inspection reveals who we really, are and what our work ethic really is.

Those who are truly following Jesus Christ will not be caught unaware. Whether Jesus comes on May 21st, August 15th, or ten years from now – it doesn’t matter. A faithful believer will always be watching because their heart is on obedience, not merely hoping we hear the sound of approaching footsteps in time to get ready.

Do I believe the Lord will one day return? Absolutely. But it will be on a day when the world and the church is unprepared. Those who become apathetic and neglect their call to discipleship will be caught by surprise. The faithful will be surprised as well, but it won’t matter for they are always ready and watching.

Here’s my prediction. Monday morning Harold Camping’s followers will be looking for jobs, and like the 41 failed rapture predicting prophets before him, he’ll have to find an excuse for being wrong.

See you in Church on Sunday.

Eddie Snipes
05/2011

Did the prophecy in Jeremiah 46 fail?

Atheist argument:
>Jeremiah 46: 13-26, ” This is the message which the Lord spoke to
>Jeremiah the prophet about the coming of Nebuchadnezzar king of Babylon
>to smite the land of Egypt … verse 19: for Memphis will become a desolation;
>it will even be burned down and bereft of inhabitants … 24: the
>daughter of Egypt has been put to shame. Given over to people of the
>north … 26: and I shall give them over to the power of those seeking
>their lives, even into the hand of Nebuchadnezzar king of Babylon and
>the hand of his officers ….”
>
>Apologetic: Still to be fulfilled.
>Rebuttal: Nebuchadnezzar is dead, and so is his empire; the prophecy
>cannot be fulfilled.
>

This prophecy you quoted has indeed been fulfilled. It was fulfilled around 586bc. In 1886 Sir Flinders Petrie discovered the ruins of a large castle. The front of this castle had a great open platform of prick work which matches Jeremiah’s claim in verse 8. This confirms Nebuchadnezzar’s annals which state that he did invade Egypt approximately 20 years after Jeremiah’s prophecy. Three inscriptions have been found near Tahpahnes confirming this as well.

I also researched Arabian historical archives and this statement referring to the deterioration of Pharaoh’s empire was taken directly from these archives:

Gradually, though, the power of the kingdom was eroded through invasion, ending ignominiously when Amasis, “the Drunkard”, was forced to depend on Greek forces to defend his Kingdom .

One mistake that people make is that they link separate prophecies and assume they will be fulfilled together. Nebuchadnezzar’s prophecy was fulfilled just as Jeremiah recorded. Nebuchadnezzar was only foretold as the one who will weaken the Egyptian defenses. The destruction of Egypt and the 40 year desolation was not concerning Nebuchadnezzar. It is unclear if the 40 year desolation ever took place. When placed inside of a historical perspective, forty years is not a long time range. It is possible that this also may have been fulfilled or it may be yet to come.

Let me give a clear example of prophecy that is assumed to be linked but is separate. In Isaiah 61 the coming of Christ is foretold:

1 The Spirit of the Lord GOD is upon me; because the LORD hath anointed me to preach good tidings unto the meek; he hath sent me to bind up the brokenhearted, to proclaim liberty to the captives, and the opening of the prison to them that are bound;
2 To proclaim the acceptable year of the LORD, and the day of vengeance of our God; to comfort all that mourn;
3 To appoint unto them that mourn in Zion, to give unto them beauty for ashes, the oil of joy for mourning, the garment of praise for the spirit of heaviness; that they might be called trees of righteousness, the planting of the LORD, that he might be glorified.

The rest of this chapter goes on to give the complete picture of all that the Messiah will fulfill including the day of vengeance and judgment upon the earth. But look at how Jesus read this prophecy in Luke 4:
17 And there was delivered unto him the book of the prophet Esaias. And when he had opened the book, he found the place where it was written,
18 The Spirit of the Lord is upon me, because he hath anointed me to preach the gospel to the poor; he hath sent me to heal the brokenhearted, to preach deliverance to the captives, and recovering of sight to the blind, to set at liberty them that are bruised,
19 To preach the acceptable year of the Lord.
20 And he closed the book, and he gave it again to the minister, and sat down. And the eyes of all them that were in the synagogue were fastened on him.
21 And he began to say unto them, This day is this scripture fulfilled in your ears.

Jesus only read what is now known as Isaiah 61 verses 1 and half of verse 2. His first coming was only to fulfill the grace of God and become salvation to those who recognize Him as Lord. The vengeance was not going to be fulfilled and the foretold earthly kingdom was not to be fulfilled until after His crucifixion and at a much later date at the promise of His return. The Jews wanted to make him king and each time they came with the idea to crown him, he deflated their ideas of making him king. The cross was essential for salvation. The earthly kingdom will be fulfilled upon His return. Both are clearly prophesied but the religious leader missed this plan because they were too busy trying to fit Christ into their prediction. They couldn’t see that God is not bound to our predictions about what He will do. When men predict wrong, they are the ones that are fallible, not God. The Bible is inspired, our predictions about how biblical prophecies will be fulfilled are not inspired but are almost always errant.

Eddie Snipes
1999

Did the prophecy in Ezekiel 26 fail?

Atheistic argument:

>Ezekiel 26:3-36 explains at length that
>Nebuchadnezzar will lay siege to Tyre and destroy it, that he will take its
>money and goods, that the city will “be built no more” and “be no more.”
>Any history book about the period will explain that Nebuchadnezzar’s
>thirteen year siege was unsuccessful. The city was later conquered by
>Alexander the Great, but it was rebuilt and is currently inhabited

Answer
Atheist frequently quote this passage as evidence so let’s dispel this myth. This argument uses half-truths to back up the atheists claim of unfulfilled prophecy. I have seen this on several atheist websites and newsgroup postings. The real tragedy with atheism is that they take as truth what is hear only from these sources and never validate these claims to find out if they are true. I have done a little research and here is the historical evidence about the fulfillment of Ezekiel’s prophecy:

Indeed Ezekiel did prophecy that Nebuchadnezzar shall lay siege and destroy Tyre. Verse 3 of the passage you cited also says that more nations will also be involved in the destruction of Tyre. Now here is the half-truth that atheist love to quote. Actually it is a series of half-truths. They claim Tyre was not destroyed – it was. They also claim that because Nebuchadnezzar didn’t finish the job, Ezekiel was wrong. Most atheist argue that Ezekiel was wrong because Alexander the Great defeated Tyre when Ezekiel 26:7-9 gives Nebuchadnezzar as the defeating leader. The half-truth is that indeed Nebuchadnezzar did defeat Tyre and fulfill exactly what the Bible says he will do. Alexander fulfilled the Bible’s claim that the timber, stones and soil would be thrown into the sea leaving Tyre as a bare rock. The Bible does not call the leader by name who would fulfill this part of the prophecy, but it clearly specifies other nations would be involved.

When Nebuchadnezzar defeated Tyre, the people fled to an island. Alexander came and these same people resisted his conquering empire. To get to the island, Alexander the Great used the remains of the city in which Nebuchadnezzar had laid siege to build a bridge to the island and thus completely destroyed the remaining city of Tyre and completely fulfilled the prophecy of Ezekiel to the letter. Ezekiel 26 verse 12 says, “they will break down your walls and destroy your pleasant houses; they will lay your stones, your timber, and your soil in the midst of the water.”

It is very important to notice Nebuchadnezzar was called by name and when he is addressed in verse 7-8 the prophecy is addressed as ‘he’…i.e., “He will slay…He will direct his battering rams…”. In verse 12 the prophecy is addressed as ‘they’, i.e., “they will plunder…they will break…they will lay your stones, timber and soul in the midst of the water”. Clearly this prophecy was not addressed to Nebuchadnezzar but rather to those who would follow.

This ‘inaccuracy’ is not as the atheist claims, but rather this prophecy was fulfilled to the exact letter proving that no one but God could have known before hand these events separated by so many years. If Nebuchadnezzar had fulfilled it all, it would have been said that he saw this prophecy and self-fulfilled it or that Ezekiel knew of Nebuchadnezzar’s plans and he prophesied accordingly. But when you see that God foretold that Nebuchadnezzar would not be able to complete the job but nations would wipe Tyre clean and when you see Nebuchadnezzar’s defeat of the city, Tyre’s flight to the island and Alexander’s bridge to the island, you can’t explain it any other way except that this Bible was inspired by God.

One important principle about biblical prophecy is that you cannot purposefully fulfill it nor can you use it to predict God. Prophecy is written so that we are prepared and so we can have confidence in God and when we see these things fulfilled we know God’s word is true and that God is in control. There are over 300 prophecies concerning Christ and many seemed contradictory thus making it impossible to self-fulfill. For example, Jesus’ parents lived outside of Bethlehem but they were forced by the Roman Empire to go to Bethlehem to register for a census and to be taxed, Jesus was born there, they fled to Egypt to escape Herod’s order to kill male children 2 years and younger, moved back and settled in Nazareth. This action fulfilled seemingly contradictory prophecies that said that Christ would be born in Bethlehem, God would call His son out of Egypt and the Christ would be called a Nazarine. This is just a sampling but proves an important point. God inspires prophecy and interweaves them with events making it completely impossible for anyone to design a self-fulfilling plan in order to fulfill by forgery. Therefore when you see these things fulfilled – such as Ezekiel’s prophecy – you know that surely, only God could have known beforehand.

Eddie Snipes
1999